Post 'March Madness Elite Eight SOTD Thread - Mar 17, 2024' of challenge 'MMarch24 Maddness Matchup 2024'

Reddit post
The number of participants is 21
  1. u/partyman97_3 posted on 2024-03-17 03:17:58-07:00 (Pacific Standard Time). Reddit Comment (See markdown)

    March 17, 2024 – Elite Eight

    • Prep: Coffee and splash of warm water
    • Brush: Wolf Whiskers w/ Elite 3-band premium badger knot
    • Razor: EldrormR Industries MM24 #MMarch24
    • Blade: Personna GEM PTFE (9)
    • Lather: Southern Witchcrafts – Carpathia
    • Post Shave: Southern Witchcrafts – Carpathia

    I was very conflicted this morning. But I really enjoy the Southern Witchcrafts stuff. I have had the Carpathia for a while now. First time using it. My sus nose kinda gets the woods after a rain. I really like it. And the lather was very pillowy. Lots of cushion and very slick.

    In now way do I mean any disrespect to Barrister and Mann. I have several of their soaps. Just had to go off script today.

    Now for coffee. Heading to the American Legion later today to meet a bunch of my guard buddies for corned beef and cabbage. Should be fun catching up. Have a great shave day all.

    MMarch24

  2. u/sahenders posted on 2024-03-17 03:54:53-07:00 (Pacific Standard Time). Reddit Comment (See markdown)

    Mar 17, 2024 - MM24 9th Match-Up: B+M vs. SW

    • Brush: AP Shave Co. Honey Ebonite 26mm G5C Fan Knot
    • Razor: EldrormR Industries MM24 #MMarch24
    • Blade: Personna GEM PTFE [17]
    • Lather: Barrister and Mann - Sandalwood - Soap
    • Post Shave: House of Mammoth/Noble Otter - Cerberus - Aftershave
    • Fragrance: Declaration Grooming/House of Mammoth - Cerberus - Eau de Parfum

    I couldn't resist the Sandalwood.

    Rating: 4/5

  3. u/EldrormR posted on 2024-03-17 05:43:00-07:00 (Pacific Standard Time). Reddit Comment (See markdown)

    March 17 SOTD * Brush: Long Shaving Storm w/ Reserve III * Razor: EldrormR Industries MM24 * Blade: PTFE * Lather: B&M Figarose * Post: B&M Figarose splash * Frag: Biblio

    MMarch24

  4. u/Impressive_Donut114 posted on 2024-03-17 05:46:18-07:00 (Pacific Standard Time). Reddit Comment (See markdown)

    Mar. 17, 2024 - March [MMarch24] Madness Bracket HSOTD

    • Brush: DSCCosmetic Jade Tuxedo 24mm
    • Razor: EldrormR Industries MM24 #MMarch24
    • Blade: Personna GEM PTFE (37)
    • Lather: Barrister and Mann - Lime - Soap

    My sample of Lime arrived yesterday! M24 Bonus Shave^© coming soon.

    Edit: I am a sucker for lime. No doubt imposed by a memory that was unearthed this morning as I worked through the lather.

    B&M Lime brightened my morning as it reminded me of my grandfather who was an English Leather man and he did wear the English Leather Lime.

    Thank you, Will, for bringing the Lime.

  5. u/Priusaurus posted on 2024-03-17 06:26:39-07:00 (Pacific Standard Time). Reddit Comment (See markdown)

    March 17, 2024

    • Prep: Hot Shower
    • Brush: Dogwood Handcrafts - Gold/Blue/Black - 26mm - Mags SHD Badger
    • Razor: EldrormR Industries - MM24 - Tag: #MMarch24
    • Blade: GEM PTFE
    • Lather: Southern Witchcrafts - Samhain Soap
    • Post Shave: Southern Witchcrafts - Samhain Splash
    • Post, Post Shave: Zingari Man - Unscented Balm

    This sub wouldn't be what it is today without phteven and Samhain is a great scent. Love Will and B&M, but I gotta ride with the underdog today.

  6. u/_walden_ posted on 2024-03-17 06:44:26-07:00 (Pacific Standard Time). Reddit Comment (See markdown)

    March 17, 2024

    • Brush: AP Shave Co. - 24mm Synbad Fan
    • Razor: EldrormR Industries MM24
    • Blade: Personna Lab Blue (5)
    • Lather: Southern Witchcrafts - Lavender - Soap
    • Post Shave: Southern Witchcrafts - Incorporeal - Aftershave
    • Post Shave: Aqua Velva - Musk - After Shave Cologne
    • Post Shave: House of Mammoth - Mood Indigo - Balm
    • Fragrance: Southern Witchcrafts/Chatillon Lux - Gravefruit II (rev. #?) (#MMarch24)

    I like to tell the story about when I invited myself to Steven and Courtney's house when I was first starting out with wetshaving.

    I only had samples up to that point, but wanted to buy my first full tub. It was during the pandemic and my job was on thin ice, so I wanted to make my $16 count. They let me come smell all they had to offer, and I walked out with a tub of Lycanthropy and a few free samples they graciously threw in. They even offered to sell me the last new tub of OG Gravefruit on earth, which I declined after smelling.

    It was really nice of them to let me into their home and smell their stuff, and Lycanthropy did not disappoint. They discontinued it, though, and I'll never forgive them.

  7. u/jwoods23 posted on 2024-03-17 07:22:59-07:00 (Pacific Standard Time). Reddit Comment (See markdown)

    Mar. 17, 2024

    • Prep: CeraVe - Hydrating Facial Cleanser

    • Brush: Muninn Woodworks Weru Burl w/ 24mm B16

    • Razor: EldrormR Industries MM24 

    • Blade: GEM PTFE (5)

    • Lather: Southern Witchcrafts -Boonana

    • Post Shave: T.N. Dickinson’s - Witch Hazel

    • Post Shave: House Of Mammoth Z (uncool) Balm

    • Fragrance: Southern Witchcrafts - Boonana

    • Tags: #MMarch24

    Feeling spooky today!

  8. u/OnionMiasma posted on 2024-03-17 07:28:11-07:00 (Pacific Standard Time). Reddit Comment (See markdown)

    March 17, 2024

    • Brush: Summer Break Soaps 'Geneva' B16 28mm
    • Razor: EldrormR Industries MM24
    • Blade: GEM PTFE (3)
    • Lather: Southern Witchcrafts - Pomona
    • Post Shave: Stirling Soap Co. - Unscented - Balm
    • Fragrance: Spearhead - Seaforth! Black Watch

    #MMarch24

    Taking the kids to the aquarium today.

  9. u/Impressive_Donut114 posted on 2024-03-17 07:28:59-07:00 (Pacific Standard Time). Reddit Comment (See markdown)

    March 17, 2024 – March [#MMarch24] Madness Mann and MOOS MM24 Bonus Shave©

    • Brush: West Coast Shaving Green Honeycomb Tuxedo 24mm
    • Razor: EldrormR Industries MM24
    • Blade: Personna GEM PTFE (38)
    • Lather: Barrister and Mann – Lime – Soap
    • Post Shave: Sir Irisch Moos – Sir Irisch Moos
  10. u/tsrblke posted on 2024-03-17 07:46:37-07:00 (Pacific Standard Time). Reddit Comment (See markdown)

    March 17, 2024

    • Brush: Chisel and Hound Brasilia V18
    • Razor: EldrormR Industries MM24
    • Blade: GEM (17)
    • Lather: Southern Witchcrafts – Boonana
    • Post Shave: Zingari Man – Traditionalist
    • Fragrance: Ralph Lauren – Ralph’s Club

    Gotta back the underdog today. Boonana again because that’s all I got. Maybe the luck of the Irish will help carry SW over the top.

    Keep using the #MMarch24 tag fellow MM24 users! We’re half-way there.

  11. u/el_guapo26 posted on 2024-03-17 07:59:35-07:00 (Pacific Standard Time). Reddit Comment (See markdown)

    Mar. 17, 2024
    Brush: Omega Pro 48
    Razor: EldrormR Industries MM24
    Blade: GEM PTFE [17]
    Lather: Southern Witchcrafts - Necromantic
    Post Shave:* Chatillon Lux - Yuzu/Rose/Patchouli

    #MMarch24

  12. u/AdWorried2804 posted on 2024-03-17 08:37:05-07:00 (Pacific Standard Time). Reddit Comment (See markdown)

    March 16, 2024 – MMarch24 Madness Elite Eight Sunday

    • Brush: Chisel & Hound Pueblo Opaque handle w/ 26mm v20 Fanchurian Badger knot
    • Razor: EldrormR Industries MM24
    • Blade: Personna PTFE Stainless Steel GEM (12)
    • Preshave: Stirling Soap Co. – Unscented
    • Lather: Southern Witchcrafts - Fougère Nemeta (2)
    • Post Shave: Spearhead Shaving – Seaforth! Heather AS Toner (2)
    • Post Shave: Zingari Man – Unscented AS Balm (184)
    • Tags: #MMarch24

    Precision Load; Face Lather; WTG/ATG/Cleanup Passes; BBS Result; 15th Consecutive / 289th Overall SOTD Post

    I spent the first half of March focusing on improving my lathering and MM24 techniques so in order to minimize variables I kept the soap base constant. It's now time to test my technique improvements on different soap bases, and the Elite Eight matchups provide the ideal opportunity to do so.

    This is a heart vs head choice. Logically speaking B&M should get my nod since it's the second highest number of tubs (after Stirling) in my stash, and a number of their scents would be great choices as desert island soaps. Instead, I went with my heart and today's vote goes to Southern Witchcrafts. Happy shaving and have a wonderful day.

  13. u/RedMosquitoMM posted on 2024-03-17 09:59:47-07:00 (Pacific Standard Time). Reddit Comment (See markdown)

    #MMarch24 Madness: Elite Eight - (1) B&M vs (8) SW

    • Brush: Chisel & Hound “Cyndi” 26mm V11 Fanchurian
    • Razor: EldrormR Industries MM24 #MMarch24
    • Blade: GEM (53)
    • Lather: Barrister and Man - Shaving Soap - Saeryan
    • Post Shave: House of Mammoth - Shire 2 - Aftershave
    • Fragrance: MISKEO Parfums - Pistil
    • Passes: WTG, XTG
    • Coffee: Sumatra. Aceh. v: Ateng. Bor Bor. Catimor. Timor. p: Washed. r: r: 02/20/24
    • Music: Kevin Morby - Lagniappe Session 2018

    We're at that point in the bracket where there's no wrong answer.

    Sadly, I have to give this one to Barrister and Mann. Will's soaps will probably go far in my tourney, occupying lots of my shelf space and featuring many of my favorite scents in the game. I also have a soft spot for Excelsior, the first elite-level base I really dialed in; it just feels correct.

    Interested to see how this game turns out.

  14. u/raymoonie posted on 2024-03-17 10:28:21-07:00 (Pacific Standard Time). Reddit Comment (See markdown)

    Mar. 17, 2024
    Brush: Dogwood Tooth Fairy B14 Badger
    Razor: EldrormR Industries MM24
    Blade: Gem PTFE [17]
    Lather: Southern Witchcrafts x Australian Private Reserve - Gravefruit - Soap
    Post Shave:* Southern Witchcrafts - Gravefruit - Aftershave

    Great afternoon shave. Go SW!

    #MMarch24

  15. u/jimm262 posted on 2024-03-17 10:52:27-07:00 (Pacific Standard Time). Reddit Comment (See markdown)

    Mar. 17, 2024
    Brush: Razorock Plissoft (24mm Synth)
    Razor: u/EldrormR Industries MM24
    Blade: Personna GEM PTFE [13]
    Lather: Barrister and Mann - Oceana - Soap

    Oceana seemed an ideal B&M choice for my final Kauai shave. Bummed we have to leave today, and am already looking forward to returning to my favorite island.

    #MMarch24

    Shared from My Shave Den for iOS

  16. u/hugbckt posted on 2024-03-17 11:01:13-07:00 (Pacific Standard Time). Reddit Comment (See markdown)

    March 17, 2024

    • Brush: TnS Mixed BoBa7
    • Razor: EldrormR Industries MM24 #MMarch24
    • Blade: Personna GEM PTFE
    • Lather: Barrister and Mann – Sunny Lane
    • Post Shave: Stirling Soap Co. – Piacenza

    If it were fall, I probably would’ve used SW (Pomona or Samhain). But for spring, Sunny Lane is one of my all-time favorites. Soft heart performs so well, even when I’m using as little soap as possible because my sample is almost out. u/BostonPhotoTourist is welcome to bring this scent back anytime (please)

  17. u/frankieIVfingers posted on 2024-03-17 11:48:30-07:00 (Pacific Standard Time). Reddit Comment (See markdown)

    Sunday, March 17, 2024

    • Brush: Dogwood Handcrafts - Bone - 28mm B16
    • Razor: EldrormR Industries - MM24 (2 Tone)
    • Blade: GEM PTFE
    • Lather: Southern Witchcrafts - Grey Phetiver - Soap
    • Post Shave: Southern Witchcrafts - Grey Phetiver - Aftershave

    MMarch24

  18. u/GroundbreakingRole45 posted on 2024-03-17 12:48:31-07:00 (Pacific Standard Time). Reddit Comment (See markdown)

    Mar. 17, 2024
    Brush: AP SHAVECO AP400B XL 28 mm (G5C)
    Razor: EldrormR Industries MM24
    Blade: Personna GEM PTFE Coated [6]
    Lather: Barrister And Mann - Seville Shaving Soap (Omnibus Base) - Soap
    Post Shave: Barrister And Mann - Seville AS Splash - Aftershave
    Post Shave: Barrister And Mann - Seville AS Balm - Balm
    Fragrance:* Barrister And Mann - Seville - EdT

    MMarch24

    Happy St. Paddy’s Day!

    Shared from My Shave Den for iOS

  19. u/Environmental-Gap380 posted on 2024-03-17 14:08:17-07:00 (Pacific Standard Time). Reddit Comment (See markdown)

    March 17, 2024

    • Brush: AP Shave Co 26mm G5A SHD
    • Razor: MM24
    • Blade: GEM PTFE
    • Lather: Barrister and Mann - Braeburn
    • Post Shave: Barrister and Mann - Nordost Splash
    • Fragrance: Barrister and Mann - Limon EdC

    MMarch24

    Over halfway through the MMarch Madness. I only have samples of Southern Witchcrafts, some of the fragrances that have the “darker” scents don’t agree with me. If I used them today, it would have been Pomona or Samhain. I had planned on a different approach today, but made a last minute switch to go all in on fruit themed scents. No surprise that these worked together, though the citrus of the splash and cologne have really diminished the amount of apple from Braeburn. Still, this is a combo I would do again. I haven’t tried to tally up the score so far, but wow is it going to be close. SW can definitely pull off the upset today.

    Edit: just did an informal +/- count, and looks like Barrister and Mann is +8 or 9. Tried to use the Blackjack card counting system, but I’m not the best at keeping a count. Going back about half way down they were even, but the earlier shaves had more streaks of Barrister and Mann than Southern Witchcrafts. This can still go either way.

  20. u/Admirable-Nobody-946 posted on 2024-03-17 17:22:04-07:00 (Pacific Standard Time). Reddit Comment (See markdown)
    • Brush: Dogwood Handcrafts “The Matterhorn” handle with Declaration Grooming B15 knot
    • Razor: EldrormR Industries - MM24
    • Blade: Gem Blue Star uncoated (7)
    • Lather: Southern Witchcrafts - Fougere Nemeta soap
    • Post Shave: Southern Witchcrafts - Fougere Nemeta splash

    MMarch24

    This was a really hard one for me. Both artisans I really connect with, but I had to give the edge to Southern Witchrafts. I heard tell that Fougere Nemeta won't be coming back this spring... That truly breaks my heart. Again so hard to decide but it may be my favorite offering from SW. I'll be sure to cherish this puck and stretch it as long as I can.

    To both Dogwood Handcrafts and Southern Witchcrafts, thank you so much for your contributions to wetshaving. I'll be dropping by to say hello at the Maggard meet up!

  21. u/Tetriside posted on 2024-03-17 20:54:18-07:00 (Pacific Standard Time). Reddit Comment (See markdown)

    March 16, 2024

    • Brush: ShoreShave Burnt Orange, Tangerine, PearlSwirl T4 Fan 26 mm
    • Razor: EldrormR MM24
    • Blade: GEM PTFE (8)
    • Lather: Southern Witchcrafts - Grey Phetiver
    • Post Shave: Osma Alum
    • Post Shave: Lucky Tiger - Aftershave and Toner
    • Post Shave: Declaration Grooming - Original Liniment
    • Fragrance: Spearhead Shaving - Three Scots

    More vetiver today. I really like this one.

    #MMarch24