Post 'Thursday Lather Games SOTD Thread - Jul 20, 2023' of challenge 'Rookie of the Year'

Reddit post
The number of participants is 18
  1. u/Crossan1983 posted on 2023-07-19 23:44:08-07:00 (Pacific Standard Time). Reddit Comment (See markdown)

    LGSOTD 20-July

    • Brush: Semogue - Galahad #OLDWORLD
    • Razor: Blackland - Vector #CNC  
    • Blade: Feather Professional   
    • Lather: Stirling Soap Co. - Ramblin' Man
    • Post Shave: Stirling Soap Co. - Ramblin' Man AS  
    • Fragrance: Stirling Soap Co. - Ramblin' Man EDT

    I have a handful of dupe sets but plumped for Stirling. This is my second ever set of Stirling, the first being Executive Man. Ramblin' Man being based on Creed Himalaya, an everyday scent that I just enjoy in itself.  Not massively strong, but inoffensive for the office. What I would really like is a Ombre Leather dupe, alas I have not been able to find one. 

    The vector is a no brainer type razor, I find I'm able to get a very close and long lasting finish with minimal effort. One of those I tend to pick up when I'm in a rush, but just felt like it today. 

    For the challenge, ok so paste it was, only briefly splashes to wet the brush and loaded heavily, and on it went. Flecks of solid Soap attached to my face and I was half tempted to go for it, nah maybe just a little bit of water. So flecks are less pronounced but more paste like, and off I roll. Half way through, it's actually not that bad, not as slick as it should be but I'm not going on raw at least. I don't think I'll be changing my normal routine in favour of paste, but it wasn't terrible. 

    Smelling good and ready for the day, but if anyone knows of an ombre dupe then please shout!

    Hope everyone has a grand day. 

    Cheers

    Marc

    ROTY

    PhotoContest

  2. u/whosgotthepudding posted on 2023-07-20 06:25:01-07:00 (Pacific Standard Time). Reddit Comment (See markdown)

    7/20/23

    Super nice shave today compared with yesterday and the sock. Scarn is a dupe of Dior Sauvage. I haven't had the pleasure of trying the original, but I'm tempted because of how much the Mrs. and I enjoy it. Spicy and woodsy, this scent has a very traditional masculine cologne scent. It's very nice and even better that it comes from a pillar of this community. In hindsight, I should've used the MOAR BOAR.

    I typically prefer my lather to be basically dripping. No peaks in the lather and should be easily rinsed off my razor, if not already slopping off. So I went with a thicker and pastier lather today. Pics. It was fine, I guess. I didn't have any irritation or razor burn, but in the end I still prefer a wetter lather with some more glide and easier rinse on my blade.

    #ROTY

  3. u/tsrblke posted on 2023-07-20 06:48:49-07:00 (Pacific Standard Time). Reddit Comment (See markdown)

    July 20, 2023 – Dupe Day

    • Brush: Maggard Synthetic
    • Razor: Gillette Tech
    • Blade: Parker (3)
    • Lather: Stirling Soap Co. – Haverford
    • Post Shave: Stirling Soap Co. – Haverford
    • Fragrance: Maher Olfactive – Treachery

    So today is the day we pay homage to the copycats in our collections. The one day we can say we saved money because we didn’t buy the expensive name brand stuff. So the challenge, I wasn’t quite sure how to handle this challenge with my newfound love for GUTL though. After all with GUTL you’re making 2 lathers basically. One on your face that’s leans dry and one in your bowl, that, if you overhydrate you can mix with the face lather to hit that sweet spot. It’s sorta a built in correction. So here I was worried I’d have to abandon the GUTL I only just now adopted. When it dawned on me, GUTL is really just the acknowledgement we’re not tied to the formalities of wetshaving just because they’re formalities. We blaze new dorito and mountain dew scent categories here. GUTL is just eschewing the old rigid categories of face and bowl lathering to do something novel that works and over engineers our shave. So as long as I’m over engineering my shave, I’m GUTLing in spririt. Basically I’m air bud ruling my GUTL here. So u/merikus and u/airbudeuler (who is definitely not u/cowzilla3) can sit down, share their commonalities as 2 sides of a coin and get along as the memes have now been poorly unified. Or not.

    Back to challenge. I’m somewhere between a medium water and too dry normally. But we’re vacationing which means, collapsible dog bowl. And I am always underhydrating in this thing, it’s why I moved to scuttle. So wet sloppy lather it is and I tried to take a picture to show it. The picture doesn’t do it justice. My wife came in to talk to me and I had to hold my face over the sink because lather was dripping everywhere.

    For #fof, I’m dickholing Haverford. Which is a dupe of Tobacco de vanille. So far fairly easy. I’ve never smelled the original but this one is quite nice. I don’t have the EdT, but I’ve finished it off with treachery. Not only do the tobaccos play well (though I find treachery to be a slight bit less sweet) but also there’s a bit of wordplay here. After all dupes are, in a sense a bit of treachery. Trying to pass a less expensive version of something as the real thing.

    Similarly, my #photocontest in the field of literature. Here we have Aristotle’s Nicomachean Ethics. Obviously an early work of philosophy literature. But also, a translation (I don’t read Greek) which is another thing you might call a dupe.

    Let’s go fellow #ROTY 10 days left. 2/3 done.

  4. u/squid_monk posted on 2023-07-20 07:31:22-07:00 (Pacific Standard Time). Reddit Comment (See markdown)

    July 20, 2023

    https://imgur.com/gallery/kmavtG6

    Prep: Proraso - Refrescante Preshave Cream

    Brush: Simpsons Commodore X3 Best Badger

    Razor: Rockwell - 6S R6 plate

    Blade: Treet - Platinum (2)

    Lather: Stirling Soap Co. - Sharp Dressed Man Shave Soap

    Post Shave: Stirling Soap Co. - Sharp Dressed Man Aftershave Splash

    Sharp Dressed Man is a dupe of Creed Green Irish Tweed.

    Challenge: I'm usually a "eh, medium water" kinda guy, so I went pasty today. Not the best shave, I definitely need a bit more slickness to my lather.

    #ROTY

  5. u/pridetwo posted on 2023-07-20 07:37:52-07:00 (Pacific Standard Time). Reddit Comment (See markdown)
    • Brush: Chisel & Hound Kuai Taper w/ V18 Fanchurian 26mm

    • Razor: Blackland Blackbird

    • Blade: Bic Chrome Platinum

    • Lather: Chicago Grooming Co. - 40

    • Post Shave: Noble Otter - Wowzers

    • Fragrance: Chanel - Allure Homme Sport

    Today's Theme: Duppelgänger - 40 is a dupe of Fucking Fabulous by Tom Ford, Wowzers is a dupe of Guilty Black by Gucci

    Today's Challenge: Water Day - A wizard's lather is never pasty, nor is it watery. He lathers precisely as he means to. So I defaulted to the pasty lather for today's challenge, which was kind of a bold choice since I was using the famously efficient Blackbird for the first time today. Honestly the shave went well, but I had to keep rinsing the blackbird after almost every stroke to keep it from clogging. By the end of the shave my neck was shedding dry soap flakes.

    My theme for today's shave: Mainstream Perfumery

    So for today's shave I wanted to do an exercise in mainstream perfumery. Tom Ford, Gucci, Chanel, these are all names that fit right at home in any department store and are known all around the world. 40's scent is really pleasant and generally somewhat floral to my nose. Wowzers smells like "artic cool" deodorant. The bottle of Allure Homme Sport is a fragrance I've had for somewhere between 15-20 years now and while I don't wear it often it's a crowd-pleasing citrus aquatic. Overall, it's a very pleasant fragrance progression, but I also don't feel like I have my own identity in these fragrances. When I put together a fragrance progression I usually want to express some sort of feeling or facet of my personality, but with this shave it felt like I was putting on someone else's smells.

    For music, I picked the most mainstream metal album I have, Iron Maiden's Brave New World. It's a good album in its own right, and some really fun songs, but also not my favorite, I like Dance of Death better personally. #photocontest #FOF #ROTY

  6. u/djanovshaving posted on 2023-07-20 08:48:53-07:00 (Pacific Standard Time). Reddit Comment (See markdown)

    Lather Games 2023 Day 20

    • Prep: Warm water
    • Brush: Mühle - Rytmo
    • Brush: Mühle - Rocca
    • Razor: Karve - The Christopher Bradley Razor
    • Blade: Gillette - Minora
    • Lather: Chicago Grooming Co. - Shiloh
    • Post Shave: Chicago Grooming Co. - Shiloh
    • Post Shave: Mühle - alum block

    Dope day! There two reason to choose today soap. One is because I never used Chicago Grooming products before. And the second is the is scent inspired by Acqua Di Parma iconic "Colonia". Its a good soap but I prefer soaps with more strong scent! I want all bathroom to be fulfilled with fragrance!!! I have a gift! I am masters of lather. Like..... Like I feel it..... She speaks to me.... Known or unknown soap I don't have problem at all. Before I start wet shaving I watched a few videos in YouTube how to make Lather. And I was lucky to watch the right one. I don't remembered who is this guy but my first lathering was test to see what's gonna happen and after that till now I don't have a problem to make it how I want it. I like it in this phase that is before dripping. Heavy and aha to drop but stays hanging on brush. So in this perfect spot I don't have choice in today challenge. So I decided to make two bowls. One dripping one almost dry!!!! Half face with wet the other half with dry. In result if I have to chose I'll take dry one. In so wet lather there is no such slickness ( maybe only in that soap after Lather games I'll test with Nod, Barrister and Stirling ). Alum block confirmed that. I feeling left side more irritated then right.

    P.S. I start make memes for this challenge and now I can't stop myself! But there is this feeling that I am like this old people not knowing what is written on their t-shirts.

    ROTY

  7. u/Dry_Fly3965 posted on 2023-07-20 09:14:07-07:00 (Pacific Standard Time). Reddit Comment (See markdown)

    Day 20 - Dupelgänger

    • Brush: Yaqi - Arctic brush with Caravel handle
    • Razor: Baili - BR179
    • Blade: Astra - Green
    • Lather: Stirling - Ramblin' Man
    • Post Shave: Stirling - Ramblin' Man Balm
    • Fragrance: Stirling - Ramblin' Man EdT

    For Dupe day, I used the dickhole. I am a big fan of Creed Himalaya dupes. I don't think I have ever tried the actual Creed Himalaya, only dupes. I don't think you can have a bad shave with Stirling. I am definitely more on the watery side for the lather. Today I am going for the lather paste. It works but definitely still prefer more water.

    ROTY #FOF

  8. u/rebdoomer88 posted on 2023-07-20 10:45:18-07:00 (Pacific Standard Time). Reddit Comment (See markdown)
    • Brush: Van Der Hagen Boar Brush
    • Razor: Parker Clip-Type Shavette Dark Sheesham Wood Handle
    • Blade: Tiger Superior
    • Lather: 345 Soap Company - Trench Lines
    • Post Shave: 345 Soap Company - Trench Lines Aftershave Splash
    • Frag: 345 Soap Company - Trench Lines EDP

    ROTY

  9. u/throwa-waaaay posted on 2023-07-20 11:20:46-07:00 (Pacific Standard Time). Reddit Comment (See markdown)

    July 20, 2023

    • Prep: Shower
    • Brush: Zenith 507U XSE
    • Razor: Chiseled Face Legacy Aluminum
    • Blade: Gillette Platinum
    • Lather: RazoRock - Irish Countryside
    • Post Shave: RazoRock - Irish Countryside
    • Fragrance: Davidoff - Cool Water

    Green Irish Tweed, Razorock Irish Countryside, 2 peas in a pod, or one dupe in a container. I've smelled a handful of GIT dupes, and the RR one is my favorite. It's a very fresh scent, comparable to the original. Speaking of the original, I finished up with some Cool Water, which was created by the same person who created GIT, they're also comparable scents as well.

    I always build a good lather, so naturally not enthused with today's challenge. Here is my pasty lather that I begrudgingly shaved with.

    Until tomorrow!

    #ROTY

  10. u/souleater7173 posted on 2023-07-20 13:00:17-07:00 (Pacific Standard Time). Reddit Comment (See markdown)

    July 20, 2023

    • Brush: Zenith Brass Handle B36 #HOLLOW
    • Razor: Karve CB (SB – C)
    • Blade: Gillette Silver Blue (7)
    • Lather: Chicago Grooming Co. (Formerly Oleo Soapworks) – Excursion
    • Post Shave: Barrister and Mann – Spice

    Huge shoutout to u/worbx for this smush. This is the first time I’ve ever tried anything from this artisan. I’m very impressed even though I had to ruin the experience with too little water. I’m not super big into the frag world, so I’m trusting the link in the post description above that Excursion is a dupe of an Yves St. Laurent scent. I really liked this scent, and the soap performance was pretty good, considering the daily challenge.

    I under watered the soap. I hated the feeling. I used a very mild razor since the lather was so sticky. Seems to have saved my face.

    Hopefully the SotD pic is enough to convince the judges for the Hollow tag. I just got this brush from EldrormR, and I’m still amazed how light it is. I really don’t see how it could be this light if it wasn’t hollow. My other brass brush would break the floor if I dropped it.

    Healthy Activity of the day: I got 10 miles today. I want to die. Here's the ride, not bad for my 320lb lard. LG Mileage: 63 miles

    Tags: #ROTY

  11. u/2SaintsDude posted on 2023-07-20 18:20:50-07:00 (Pacific Standard Time). Reddit Comment (See markdown)

    JULY 20, 2023

    • Brush: Stirling Synthetic 24mm
    • Razor: Paragon - Shaving ‘Don’ DE razor
    • Lather: Taylor of Old Bond Street - Royal Forest.
    • Post Shave: Zingari Man - Navigator

    Good old TOBS to get my mood elevated again. I have been abusing my face all week and today is like taking a breath of fresh air. Such a great scent! It’s blackcurrant, patchouli, and some vanilla, maybe pepper and more. It’s a dupe of Creed Aventus and now I know why it’s popular. My navigator splash was a somewhat close match but didn’t stand the trials of time. After a couple hours the scent disappeared.

    TODAY’s CHALLENGE: Was interesting to say the least. Used 1/3 of the water I usually use and the lather was crazy pasty. Although very slick it felt more like it was pulling moisture out of my skin than the usual hydration feel. Maybe that’s what putting salt in your face feels like!! Ya’ll have a good one.

    ROTY

  12. u/curbside_champ posted on 2023-07-20 18:22:52-07:00 (Pacific Standard Time). Reddit Comment (See markdown)

    July 20, 2023 – Dupelgänger

    • Brush: Paladin Chief 26mm Satin Juma Smoke
    • Razor: Blackland Blackbird Ti
    • Blade: Astra SP (4)
    • Lather: Ariana & Evans – Vanille de Tabac
    • Post Shave: Ariana & Evans – Vanille de Tabac splash
    • Fragrance: Duke Cannon – Old Glory solid cologne

    The Shave: Admittedly I have a hard time lathering this soap and usually use it in a more paste like form. Seeing as how its Water Day, I added significantly more water and made a thin runny lather. This was especially fun trying to put on as it just dripped off my brush and ran down my face. The shave was just as bad as the runny lather provided little in the way of cushion.

    Post Shave: Seeing as how its dupe day I went ahead and used the matching splash to ease my face after its second day of shit show shaving. I followed that up a little Duke Cannon solid cologne.

    Theme: Vanille de Tabac is a dupe of Tom Ford’s Tobacco Vanille as listed on Thirsty Badger. The Old Glory fit in with its similar warm tobacco scent.

    Challenge: I turned my normally pasty lathering into a watery mess.

    #ROTY

  13. u/TheStallionPartThree posted on 2023-07-20 18:27:27-07:00 (Pacific Standard Time). Reddit Comment (See markdown)

    July 20, 2023 – Ciao!

    • Brush: Extro Comesi Synthetic 26mm
    • Razor: Gillette Tech
    • Blade: Gillette Silver Blue (3)
    • Lather: Stirling Soap Co. – Piacenza
    • Post Shave: Chicago Grooming Co. (Formerly Oleo Soapworks) – Shiloh

    Acqua do Parma Colonia. This was my first artisan aftershave. What I wore on my first date with my partner. Eight months later we were walking by the AdP storefront next to the Spanish steps in Rome. Life is good, love is good, and these dupes serve to always remind me of that. Shiloh is a big bright lemon head. Drying down into something sparkly and powdery and beautiful. Stirlings Piacenza is a bit more muted and earthier. Not overwhelming but clean, setting you up for the sharp splash from Shiloh. I built a quick but great lather with my tricolor Italian flag brush that I purchased just outside the Vatican walls. This is too good a memory and scent for me to waste a shitty lather on. Love on. 🤙

    ROTY

  14. u/AdWorried2804 posted on 2023-07-20 18:48:25-07:00 (Pacific Standard Time). Reddit Comment (See markdown)

    July 20, 2023 – Month of Lather Day 20

    • Brush: DS Cosmetics Jade Green handle w/ DSC 24mm SHD G7 Synthetic knot
    • Razor: Gillette Tech
    • Blade: Treet Carbon Steel (4)
    • Preshave: Stirling Soap Co. – Unscented
    • Lather: Stirling Soap Co. – Stirling Blu
    • Post Shave: Stirling Soap Co. – Stirling Blu Balm
    • Music: Sudden Lights - Backwards In Time

    Daily Theme: Stirling Blu is Stirling's "take on the popular Polo Blue cologne". Polo Blue is a favorite of my wife, so it was only natural that Blu was the first Stirling soap I purchased.

    The Challenge/Shave: For decades I used Proraso and for decades my lather was a dry, pasty, and sticky. I instinctively added large quantities of water as I shaved and somehow got decent shaves in spite of my crappy lather. When I switched to artisan soaps, my Proraso lather technique was a failure and shaving was torture. Thanks to the r/Wetshaving wiki and a lot of practice I learned how to make nice, good, wet lather. Now the Lather Gods (LGs) want me to go backwards in time and relive the trauma. For reasons I cannot explain I complied. I would show you a W_E-quality photo of my hot mess razor burned face on fire, but everyone has suffered enough already.

    Public Apology: Yesterday I hypothesized that the LGs were using us to satisfy their dark web fantasies. I couldn't be more wrong, and today's shave proved it. The LGs gave us a nibble (Dup of our choice) and then made us self-torture ourselves with said dup. This is Psychological Warfare at its highest level, Stockholm Syndrome-level torture. Don't believe me? Exhibit #1 - The Lord of Spice himself, u/cowzilla3. After expressing fealty to the Air Bud Emperor, The LGs used their crowd psychology techniques to get Cowzilla to reject u/airbudeuler, bend his knee, and become a Public Shill to the Lather Gods. They broke Cowzilla, now they're trying to break us. Don't trust anyone! #ROTY

  15. u/blipsnchitz7 posted on 2023-07-20 18:50:09-07:00 (Pacific Standard Time). Reddit Comment (See markdown)

    Jul. 20, 2023
    Brush: AP Shave Co G5C
    Razor: Karve CB
    Blade: Astra SP Green
    Lather: Stirling Soap Co. - Executive Man - Soap
    Post Shave:* Stirling Soap Co. - Executive Man - Aftershave

    A pasty shave it was. And it wasn’t very fun lol.

    ROTY

  16. u/Banedon38 posted on 2023-07-20 20:45:33-07:00 (Pacific Standard Time). Reddit Comment (See markdown)

    July 20, 2023

    • Brush: Yaqi Rocks 28mm
    • Razor: Leaf Elite
    • Blade: BIC Chrome Platinum (2)
    • Lather: Chicago Grooming Co. (Formerly Oleo Soapworks) – Shiloh
    • Post Shave: RazoRock – XXX
    • Fragrance: RazoRock – XXX

    Shiloh is a dupe of Acqua Di Parma Colonia, and to me it is a very fresh smelling cologne scent. RazoRock XXX is also a dupe of the same scent. A very nice overall shave.

    A pasty lather? As a head shaver I already have problems sometimes with the lather drying out if I take my time. I gave it a shot, and things got rather...sticky at times. I don't think I will be reverting, and I definitely prefer a wetter/drippier lather.

    #ROTY

  17. u/Admirable-Nobody-946 posted on 2023-07-20 21:05:40-07:00 (Pacific Standard Time). Reddit Comment (See markdown)
    • Brush: Simpson Classic #1 synthetic brush
    • Razor: Friedrich Herder Abraham Sohn 49 straight razor
    • Lather: Stirling Soap Company - Executive Man
    • Post Shave: Noble Otter - Bare Splash

    ROTY

    Late post been driving all day hope it still counts! The shave did happen earlier. I borrowed this sample puck from a friend and it just so happens to be the very first puck I ever shaved with. Smells great like I remember.

    Went sloppy with it as I usually go pasty and slowly add water but usually not enough.

  18. u/AndImLars posted on 2023-07-20 21:55:13-07:00 (Pacific Standard Time). Reddit Comment (See markdown)

    July. 20, 2023 - SOTD 

    • Prep: Splash of warm water
    • Brush: Oumo O4 Venus SHD Badger Brush 26MM
    • Razor: West Coast Shaving Multi Titanium Collection Razor
    • Blade: King C Gillette
    • Lather: Stirling Soap Co - Haverford
    • Post Shave: Nivea Men - Sensitive Soothing Aftershave Balm

    One of the few the proud non Aventus dupe users today.

    ROTY